Celebrate American Cheese Month all of May! Every order will receive a gift of a featured cheese. This week: Rumiano Dry Jack!

Made For Each Other
Made For Each Other
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Made For Each Other
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Made For Each Other

Made For Each Other

Regular price
Sale price
Regular price
Sold out
Unit price

With new pairings for Spring ‘22! Learn the principles of pairings while you introduce your taste buds to an elevated experience. We’ve meticulously curated unique pairings featuring three artisanal cheeses and their culinary soulmates. Our new collection includes specialized cheeses like Capriago from Bohemian Creamery—new in our artisan lineup. Put it all together with our “Principles of Pairing” information card describing the pairings and why they work. It’s designed to give you the tools to create your own unique pairings once you’ve polished off this collection.

*To protect the quality of our products, we only ship (via UPS) Monday through Wednesday with 1-2 days of transit time, depending on the shipping method you select.


Capriago (5 ounces)
Sebastopol, California
Capriago is an asiago-style cheese made from goat’s milk and aged between eight and ten weeks. The rind is washed with brine at the beginning of the aging process then allowed to cultivate a wild blue mold on its rind, promoting a moist, nutty, and slightly sweet paste. This cheese pairs well with tart fruits, hoppy beers, or one of Sonoma County’s many Pinots.

Chevre (8 ounces)
Willows, California
A classic chevre with light acidity, citrus notes and a clean finish. This pasteurized, fresh cheese is made from milk sourced from local goat farms in Sacramento Valley.

Highway 1 (6 ounces)
Valley Ford, California
A unique take on traditional Fontina. This hand-crafted, old style Italian cheese is made from 100% Jersey cows from the rural coast of Sonoma. Aged for 80 days, the semi-firm, buttery-colored cheese has a silky and creamy texture and is mildly fruity, with a nutty flavor and aroma.  

California Wildflower Honey
(4 ounces)
Chico, California
Fruit and floral overtones mingle with notes of fresh grass and sun-dried hay in this complex, yet oh so smooth and mellow golden honey.

Pink Guava Jam (3.5 ounce jar)
Pacifica, California
Small Batch Jam Co.’s Pink Guava Jam is a reflection of co-founder Pablo’s Cuban heritage; growing up in a home where fresh guava and cheese were a desert held in high regard. Expect bright, juicy notes of tropical fruit tempered by citric acid and sugar with this fan favorite.

Preserved Lemon Puree (4 ounces)
Petaluma, California